That’s Amore Pizzeria Cozumel

Nestled in the heart of Cozumel’s Centro district, That’s Amore Pizzeria Cozumel is a true gem for pizza lovers craving authentic, high-quality pies crafted with passion and precision. This charming pizzeria brings a slice of Italy to the island, specializing in delectable, wood-fired Neapolitan and New York-style pizzas that are as visually tantalizing as they are bursting with flavor.

The menu at That’s Amore is thoughtfully curated to please a variety of tastes, featuring classics like the Margherita — a harmonious blend of tangy tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, fragrant parmesan, and fresh basil that delivers a perfect balance of freshness and richness. The Pepperoni pizza offers generous layers of spicy, robust pepperoni atop the melty cheese and classic tomato base, while the standout Hot Honey Pepperoni adds an irresistible twist with housemade hot honey drizzled over loaded pepperoni, marrying smoky spice with subtle sweetness in every bite.

For those seeking something playful and unexpected, the Hawaiian pizza stands out, featuring caramelized pineapple that adds a luscious, tropical sweetness, perfectly offset by smoked ham and the signature savory tomato sauce. Beyond pizzas, don’t miss the Sweaty Balls — oven-baked pizza dough balls slathered in housemade garlic butter and parmesan, a heavenly appetizer that has won the hearts of many local aficionados. The Garlic Bread offers a comforting, cheesy bite with its crispy crust layered with robust garlic butter and mozzarella. Enthusiasts can even take home a bottle of the coveted housemade hot honey to drizzle on their own creations.

The dining atmosphere at That’s Amore is warm and inviting, amplified by the genuine hospitality of owners Nancy and Ed, whose passion for pizza and community shines through every interaction. Guests consistently praise the cozy, neighborhood vibe where you’re greeted like a longtime friend the moment you step in. For many, the combination of authentic flavors, high-quality ingredients, and heartfelt service turns dining here into an unforgettable experience rather than just a meal.

Visitors rave not only about the food’s impeccable quality but also about the palpable joy and expertise behind every pizza. As one enthusiastic guest noted, the pizzas at That’s Amore transcend the local expectation of “island pizza” to deliver a “good for everywhere” experience — authentic, fresh, flavorful, and expertly baked. Whether you’re a fan of the classic Margherita or eager to try the innovative Hot Honey Pepperoni, each bite resonates with care and craftsmanship.

Conveniently located on 10 Avenida Norte between streets 2 and 4, That’s Amore invites both locals and travelers to indulge in an elevated pizza experience in the heart of Cozumel. And while they don’t serve alcohol, guests love the flexibility of bringing their own drinks from nearby establishments, making each visit perfectly tailored to individual preferences.

In short, That’s Amore Pizzeria is more than a place to eat—it’s where the magic of handmade pizza, warm service, and a welcoming atmosphere come together. Whether you’re savoring a thin, chewy crust New York-style slice or sampling their signature extras, this pizzeria leaves a lasting impression, making it a must-visit culinary destination on the island.